Our new Substack will provide another way to follow the Center’s work, with a particular emphasis on Legal Spirits, our podcast on law and religion. We’ll use it to share new podcast episodes, highlight some of the ideas and conversations behind them, and occasionally call attention to Center programs and commentary.
The Substack will supplement, not replace, the Law and Religion Forum. The Forum will remain our primary blog and the home of our written commentary, weekly Around the Web scholarship roundups, Center news, and archives.
We also hope Substack will allow us to connect with a wider community of scholars, lawyers, journalists, and others interested in law, religion, culture, and public life.
Here are some important law-and-religion news stories from around the web:
Seven employees of the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene have filed a federal lawsuit alleging anti-Jewish discrimination after the agency twice denied recognition to a Jewish employee resource group.
In a 2-1 decision, the 8th Circuit held that an Arkansas sheriff and two correctional officers were entitled to qualified immunity in a pretrial detainee’s First Amendment suit alleging that jail policies improperly restricted access to religious materials, finding that no clearly established right had been violated.
A New York federal district court allowed parents’ § 1983 claims against a school district to proceed, finding that allegations of persistent antisemitic bullying of their son, coupled with administrators’ repeated failures to intervene despite receiving complaints, plausibly established municipal liability under Monell.
A federal grand jury in the Southern District of Florida has indicted 58-year-old Brian Charles for allegedly mailing antisemitic letters threatening violence to Jewish organizations and individuals under Secret Service protection, in violation of 18 U.S.C. § 876(c).
A Tennessee federal district court held that the state’s requirement that publicly funded charter schools be nonsectarian and nonreligious violates the First Amendment’s Free Exercise Clause by excluding otherwise eligible schools based on their religious character.
St. Mary’s Catholic Parish School in Colorado (Becket)
“Why not seek the win/win?” Justice Brett Kavanaugh posed that question to Colorado’s attorney during oral argument last week in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, a case involving Catholic preschools and the state’s nondiscrimination requirements. With thousands of preschools participating in Colorado’s program, why couldn’t the state accommodate a small number of Catholic schools while protecting the interests of families headed by same-sex couples?
In this Legal Spirits Short Take, Mark Movsesian takes Kavanaugh’s question as a starting point for a broader reflection: Why is compromise so difficult in conflicts between religious freedom and LGBTQ equality? He explores how these disputes implicate deeply held convictions on both sides about identity and dignity—and why even seemingly practical accommodations can prove so elusive. Listen in!
Here are some important law-and-religion news stories from around the web:
The U.S. Supreme Court heard oral arguments in St. Mary Catholic Parish v. Roy, where a majority seemed to agree with the Catholic preschools that requiring them to adhere to Colorado’s nondiscrimination agreement to participate in the state’s universal preschool program constitutes a free exercise violation.
In a 2-1 decision, the First Circuit declined to enjoin Maine’s school vaccination requirement on grounds that it violates parents’ free exercise rights.
The West Virginia Supreme Court of Appeals dismissed local churches’ claims that United Methodist officials gave them false information about disaffiliating, holding that the fraud exception to ecclesiastical abstention does not reach mere misinterpretations of church law.
The 11th Circuit rejected a Hebrew Israelite prisoner’s claim that Florida burdened his religious exercise by denying him holiday meals and re-enrollment in its religious diet program.
A federal district court in New Mexico temporarily blocked the National Park Service from issuing a permit to kill eagles in Valles Caldera after plaintiffs argued it would burden their religious exercise under RFRA.
An Ohio trial court let the state’s suit proceed against Hebrew Union College over closing its Cincinnati rabbinical school, rejecting the argument that the First Amendment bars the case.
Alabama voters approved a constitutional amendment requiring public schools to adopt daily Pledge of Allegiance policies and allowing student-led prayer, with about 63% of the vote.
One of the most important trends in American religion in recent decades has been the rise of the “Nones,” Americans who tell pollsters they have no religious affiliation. Some observers see this trend as evidence of the continuing secularization of American society. But is religion really in decline? And how much can surveys tell us about Americans’ religious beliefs and practices?
In this episode of Legal Spirits, Center Director Mark Movsesian interviews historian Thomas Kidd about his provocative new co-authored book, The Death of Religion? Nones, Others, and the Flourishing of Faith. They discuss why conventional surveys may exaggerate religious decline, the surprisingly long history of religious disaffiliation in America—including the eighteenth- and nineteenth-century phenomenon of the “Nothingarians”—and whether Americans’ longstanding suspicion of institutions helps explain the rise of the Nones today. Listen in!
Here are some important law-and-religion news stories from around the web:
The Ninth Circuit upheld an injunction blocking enforcement of a California law that restricted employers from requiring employees to attend meetings concerning political or religious matters, holding that the law infringed employers’ free speech rights.
A former Texas public school teacher sued his school district, alleging that evangelical Christian prayers at mandatory staff meetings violated the First Amendment.
A Maryland federal district court declined to grant additional injunctive relief to a rabbi challenging a county firearms restriction that prevents him from carrying a gun while walking to synagogue on the Sabbath.
A California appellate court rejected First Amendment challenges to the admission of evidence concerning Scientology’s teachings in the criminal trial of actor Danny Masterson.
A Florida federal district court dismissed a pastor’s lawsuit challenging the denial of a property tax exemption for church property, holding that the Tax Injunction Act barred federal court intervention.
A New York appellate court upheld penalties against a clothing retailer that refused to sell a bridal outfit for a same-sex wedding, rejecting the retailer’s First Amendment defense.
A Michigan federal district court dismissed a former school bus driver’s lawsuit challenging her termination for distributing candy bearing religious messages to students, holding that her conduct was not protected private religious expression.
This fall, the Mattone Center hosted a reading group that brought together students and alumni to explore questions of faith, morality, law, and the human experience through C.S. Lewis’s Mere Christianity. Mark Lanier, an attorney, scholar, and founder of the Lanier Theological Library in Houston led the four-part series at his firm’s office in Midtown Manhattan. He guided participants through Lewis’s influential work, which began as a series of BBC radio broadcasts during World War II and later appeared as a book. The group examined Lewis’s effort to articulate the core beliefs shared across Christian traditions, using his arguments as a starting point for thoughtful discussion about morality, responsibility, and what it means to live a good life.
The discussions began with Lewis’s argument that people recognize a moral law they did not create, yet repeatedly fail to live up to it. From there, the group considered Lewis’s Christian explanation for the gap between moral knowledge and human behavior, including the roles of human freedom, evil, and Christ’s atonement. The sessions then turned to the practical demands of Christian conduct, exploring forgiveness, pride, humility, and the limits of law in shaping individual character and a just society. These themes raised questions particularly relevant to the legal profession: Can law establish the standards necessary for a good society without being able to make people good? Can forgiveness coexist with punishment and accountability? When does professional ambition become pride? In the final session, participants considered Lewis’s reflections on the Trinity, individualism and community, the purposes of church and state, and his central claim that Christianity seeks not merely outwardly respectable behavior, but the transformation of the whole person.
For law students, the reading group offered an opportunity to step beyond the rules, doctrines, and analytical frameworks that ordinarily shape legal education and reflect on the moral questions underlying the practice of law. Lewis’s arguments invited participants to consider both the power and the limitations of legal institutions: law can establish standards, identify wrongdoing, assign responsibility, and provide remedies, but it cannot by itself cultivate the virtues on which a healthy society depends. Discussions of forgiveness and accountability also offered a way to examine the distinction between pursuing justice and seeking vengeance, while reflections on pride challenged students to think critically about competition, ambition, and professional success. By connecting a classic work of Christian thought with questions about legal responsibility, public life, and personal character, the group created space for students to engage with difficult ideas, test their assumptions, and consider not only what lawyers do but what kind of people they aspire to become.
A group of Catholic moral theologians is urging a federal appeals court to support “defined normative boundaries” regarding AI use in the military.
The Fourth Circuit affirmed a Maryland federal district court’s holding that Catholic Relief Services violated Title VII and the Maryland Fair Employment Practices Act by denying health insurance coverage to an IT analyst’s same-sex spouse.
The Virginia Supreme Court has dismissed an appeal from McLean Bible Church (MBC) that sought to end a lawsuit brought by longtime members over the church’s 2021 elder election and other concerns.
Here are some important law-and-religion news stories from around the web:
Archbishop Timothy Broglio, who oversees the spiritual care of Catholic members of the United States armed forces, released a strongly worded statement raising objections to the plan to broadcast the execution of Fort Hood shooter Nidal Hasan. He also declared that Catholic members of the US Army must not participate in the firing squad.
In Lajara v. McMenamin, a Pennsylvania appeals court vacated a custody order that prohibited either parent from influencing, restricting or limiting their child’s participation in religious services, events or activities.
In Domanic v. Christian Brothers Automative Corporation, the 5th Circuit held that a Texas religion-based franchisor did not violate federal civil rights laws by requiring that its franchisees be professing Christians.
A Christian evangelist filed suit earlier this month in an Arizona federal district court challenging Tucson’s decision to exclude religious, political, and issue-based leafleting at an annual holiday display. The complain alleges this exclusion violates plaintiff’s free speech, free exercise and due process rights.
Christian Counselors in Lincoln Nebraska filed suit last week in federal district court to enjoin enforcement of city ordinances that prohibit conversion therapy for minors, alleging that the challenged rules are almost identical to the Colorado statute that the U.S. Supreme Court found unconstitutional on free speech grounds in Chiles v. Salazar.
Here are some important law-and-religion news stories from around the web:
The U.S. Supreme Court agreed to hear a Catholic order’s challenge to a denial of a permit to build a shrine next to its church. The case could provide clarity on protections for houses of worship against restrictive local zoning.
The U.S. Supreme Court may also take up the Texas and Louisiana Ten Commandments classroom laws, according to CBS’s new-term preview.
The Archdiocese of St. Louis sued in federal district court over a detention center policy that bars priests from giving Communion and hearing confessions, claiming the policy denies detainees spiritual care core to their faith.
A federal district court in New Jersey dismissed without prejudice the Justice Department’s FACE Act suit over a 2024 protest outside a synagogue, ruling that the complaint did not allege a violation of the statute’s protections for worship.
Secretary Pete Hegseth announced a Pentagon Office of Religious Affairs reporting directly to him to advocate for military chaplains and religious support.
The Justice Department’s Task Force to Combat Antisemitism announced the first stop of a national “American Tour Against Hate” in Michigan.
President Trump issued a Columbus Day proclamation that invokes devotion to God in describing the nation’s origins.
In his new book, So Ordered, Justice Alito said that the 2015 Obergefell v. Hodges decision, which legalized marriage equality in all 50 states, was “perhaps the decisive point in our nation’s turn against religious liberty.”